Files changed

• .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_US_4_PASS.md

Briefing

You are the QA Agent.

Based on the rules you must follow in the file .milkyflow/agents/qa/rules_qa_agent.md,
perform the validation of work item US_4 of EPIC_1, specified in
'.milkyflow/agents/product_owner/EPIC_1/US_4.md'.

The acceptance criteria in that file are your test script. Execute them literally, black-box,
against the deployed environment:

- Where to reach the app and test accounts: the "Endpoints" and "Access" sections of
  .milkyflow/agents/devops/prompts/EPIC_1_US_4/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md
- Precondition: .milkyflow/agents/devops/answers/EPIC_1_US_4/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md
  exists and reports READY. If it does not, stop and report: there is no deployed environment.

Do NOT read the developer answer files under .milkyflow/agents/developer/answers/ or any completion
report before testing — they describe what was claimed, and reading them first biases the test.

For each acceptance criterion, record a verdict: PASS / FAIL / BLOCKED.
Also perform the generic negative checks from your rules where applicable (invalid input
produces a clear error, not a crash or silent success; the previous story's core flow still
works).

For every FAIL, create a NEW bug report at .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_BUG_$n.md
with the next available bug number, following section 5 of your rules: the `Status: OPEN`
marker, an integer "## Bug Occurrence", and — only if the defect repeats one already reported
in this epic — a "## Previous occurrence" link plus the threshold check
(`qa.max_bug_occurrences`, default 3; at the threshold you escalate to the Project Manager
instead of filing again). A bug is a work item of the EPIC: never attach it to this story.
Record the story only under "## Detected during", which nothing routes on.

The work item is validated only if ALL acceptance criteria PASS. Report the overall verdict.
If it is validated, create the pass document at
.milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_US_4_PASS.md following the format in your rules
(section 6) — the Solution Architect cannot start the next work item without it.
If the run does NOT validate the story (any FAIL or BLOCKED), create or update the blocked
document at .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_US_4_BLOCKED.md following the same
section — a verdict that lives only in a chat message does not exist.
Cite DEPLOY_CONFIG_1 and the deployment answer in every report's Environment section.

Output

● Read US_4.md
  │ .milkyflow/agents/product_owner/EPIC_1/US_4.md
  └ 95 lines read

● Read DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md
  │ .milkyflow/agents/devops/answers/EPIC_1_US_4/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md
  └ 186 lines read

● Read rules_qa_agent.md
  │ .milkyflow/agents/qa/rules_qa_agent.md
  └ 433 lines read

Good — deployment answer reports **READY**. Now let me read the deploy config for endpoints/access details.

● Read DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md
  │ .milkyflow/agents/devops/prompts/EPIC_1_US_4/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md
  └ 173 lines read

/ Search (glob)
  │ ".milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_BUG_*.md"
  └ 1 file found

● Read EPIC_1_BUG_1.md
  │ .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_BUG_1.md
  └ 119 lines read

Now let me check previous US pass documents and existing bug reports so I know the baseline, then run the acceptance criteria tests.

/ Search (glob)
  │ ".milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_US_*_PASS.md"
  └ 3 files found

● List registered sources (shell)
  │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture source list 2>&1
  └ 5 lines…

Both sources are present. Now let me execute the acceptance criteria tests:

● AC1: Run capture for source-1 (shell)
  │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run qa-test-source-1 2>&1; echo "---EXIT:$?"
  └ 13 lines…

● AC1/AC2: Run capture for source-2 (shell)
  │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run qa-test-source-2 2>&1; echo "---EXIT:$?"
  └ 14 lines…

● AC1: Verify per-source run histories (shell)
  │ echo "=== run list source-1 ===" && PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run list
  │ qa-test-source-1 2>&1 && echo "=== run list source-2 ===" && PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH"
  │ backup-cockpit raw-capture run list qa-test-source-2 2>&1
  └ 11 lines…

● AC1: Verify artifact directories are isolated (shell)
  │ echo "=== captures source-1 ===" && ls local/captures/qa-test-source-1/ && echo "=== captures
  │ source-2 ===" && ls local/captures/qa-test-source-2/
  └ 5 lines…

● AC2/AC3: Source status command (shell)
  │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture source status 2>&1
  └ 5 lines…

All three ACs look good from the positive path. Let me run the generic negative checks and a US_3 regression touch.

● Negative: invalid source IDs produce clear errors (shell)
  │ echo "=== invalid source run ===" && PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run
  │ nonexistent-source 2>&1; echo "---EXIT:$?" && echo "=== invalid source status ===" &&
  │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run list nonexistent-source 2>&1; echo
  │ "---EXIT:$?"
  └ 8 lines…

● US_3 regression: readiness check still works (shell)
  │ echo "=== US_3 regression: readiness check ===" && PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit
  │ raw-capture readiness check qa-test-source-1 2>&1; echo "---EXIT:$?"
  └ 13 lines…

All tests complete. Here are the verdicts:

| Criterion | Verdict |
|---|---|
| AC1 — Per-source isolation preserved | **PASS** |
| AC2 — One server failure does not invalidate others | **PASS** |
| AC3 — Operator can verify deadline readiness per critical server | **PASS** |
| Negative: invalid input → clear error | **PASS** |
| Regression: US_3 readiness check | **PASS** |

All criteria PASS. Creating the pass document:

● Check reports directory (shell)
  │ ls /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/
  └ 8 lines…

● Create EPIC_1_US_4_PASS.md +41
  └ .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_US_4_PASS.md

Now append the history row:

● Append history row (shell)
  │ cat >> /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/history.md << 'EOF'
  │ | 2026-08-05T00:01:00Z | QA — QA Agent | story_validation | {"epic_id": "EPIC_1", "work_item":
  │ "US_4", "config_k": "DEPLOY_CONFIG_1", "verdict": "PASS"} |
  │ EOF
  └ 1 line…

---

## Overall Verdict: **PASS** ✅

All three acceptance criteria passed on first run:

| AC | Verdict | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| AC1 — Per-source isolation | **PASS** | `run list` and `local/captures/` show strictly partitioned artifacts and histories |
| AC2 — One failure doesn't invalidate others | **PASS** | source-1 PARTIAL failure did not block source-2's independent run and status |
| AC3 — Deadline-criticality visible | **PASS** | `source status` shows `[CRITICAL]` for source-1 and `-` for source-2, with dedicated `LAST_SUCCESSFUL` column |
| Negative check | **PASS** | Invalid source IDs produce clear errors, no crash |
| US_3 regression | **PASS** | Readiness check still reports READY with all checks green |

Pass document created at `.milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_US_4_PASS.md`. The Solution Architect may proceed to the next work item.



Changes    +41 -0
AI Credits 34.7 (1m 49s)
Tokens     ↑ 530.5k (494.5k cached, 32.3k written) • ↓ 4.4k (933 reasoning)
Resume     copilot --resume=d054c443-40c0-48d0-a2a5-330ac3f20ccc