Run0032_20260805T000431Z
Nodeqa_e2e_execution
RoleQA
Agentcopilot
Result
OK
Started2026-08-05T00:00:32.646220+00:00
Duration239.2s
Files changed1
Commits0
Files changed
- .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_E2E_BLOCKED.md
Briefing
You are the QA Agent. Based on the rules you must follow in the file .milkyflow/agents/qa/rules_qa_agent.md, execute the end-to-end test plan '.milkyflow/agents/product_owner/EPIC_1/e2e_test_plan.md' exactly as written, in order. - Where to reach the app and test accounts: the "Endpoints" and "Access" sections of .milkyflow/agents/devops/prompts/EPIC_1_E2E/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md - Precondition: .milkyflow/agents/devops/answers/EPIC_1_E2E/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md exists and reports READY. If it does not, stop and report: there is no deployed environment. For each test of the plan, record PASS / FAIL / BLOCKED with evidence (what was observed, screenshots when available). Do not silently adapt steps that cannot be executed as written — a non-executable step is a defect of the plan and must be reported to the Product Owner. For every FAIL, create a bug report at .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_BUG_$n.md with the next available bug number, following the format in your rules. Report the overall verdict for the epic: the epic's e2e validation passes only if ALL tests of the plan PASS. Cite DEPLOY_CONFIG_1 and the deployment answer in every report's Environment section.
Output
Let me read all required files in parallel. ● Read DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md │ .milkyflow/agents/devops/prompts/EPIC_1_E2E/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md └ 171 lines read ● Read e2e_test_plan.md │ .milkyflow/agents/product_owner/EPIC_1/e2e_test_plan.md └ 323 lines read ● Read rules_qa_agent.md │ .milkyflow/agents/qa/rules_qa_agent.md └ 433 lines read ● Read DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md │ .milkyflow/agents/devops/answers/EPIC_1_E2E/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md └ 173 lines read The deployment answer reports **READY**. Now I'll execute the test plan. Let me check existing bug reports first, then run all tests. / Search (glob) │ ".milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/*.md" └ 8 files found ● Check migrations and CLI entry point (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" alembic current 2>&1 && PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit --help 2>&1 └ 14 lines… Environment is confirmed. Let me now check the preconditions from the test plan and begin T1. ● Verify seed data sources registered (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture source list 2>&1 └ 5 lines… Both sources confirmed. Note: the test plan's preconditions reference `backup-cockpit raw-capture source update --source-id qa-test-source-1 --critical` — that's the known incorrect syntax (positional argument, not flag), but it's in the Seed Data section. This is a defect of the plan that I'll note. The environment is still correctly seeded per the deploy answer. Let me execute T1 now. **T1 — Full single-source pipeline** ● T1 step 2: readiness check source 1 (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture readiness check qa-test-source-1 2>&1 └ 11 lines… T1 Step 3: READY, all checks listed as OK. Now step 4: ● T1 step 4: run capture source 1 (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run qa-test-source-1 2>&1 └ 12 lines… Run completed with status **PARTIAL**. Run ID: `e0b7f550-2c37-4538-ae10-a236fa62fb25`. The database dump step failed (mysqldump exited code 1). Let me continue with T1 steps 6–11: ● T1 step 6: run list source 1 (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run list qa-test-source-1 2>&1 └ 5 lines… T1 Step 7: run `e0b7f550…` is listed with status PARTIAL (as expected for partial run). Start and end timestamps present. Source ID is `qa-test-source-1`. ✓ Now step 8 — artifact validate: ● T1 step 10: ls captures dir (shell) │ ls -la local/captures/qa-test-source-1/ 2>&1 └ 5 lines… ● T1 step 8: artifact validate (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture artifact validate qa-test-source-1 │ e0b7f550-2c37-4538-ae10-a236fa62fb25 2>&1; echo "EXIT:$?" └ 7 lines… ● T1 step 11: inspect artifact contents (shell) │ ls -la local/captures/qa-test-source-1/e0b7f550-2c37-4538-ae10-a236fa62fb25/ 2>&1 └ 6 lines… ● Check manifest content (shell) │ cat local/captures/qa-test-source-1/e0b7f550-2c37-4538-ae10-a236fa62fb25/manifest.json 2>&1 └ 25 lines… **T1 Assessment:** - Step 3: READY ✓, all 5 checks listed OK, no secrets ✓ - Step 7: run `e0b7f550…` listed with status PARTIAL, start/end timestamps present, source_id = `qa-test-source-1` ✓ - Step 9: `artifact validate` exits 0, outputs "Result: VALID" ✓, no credentials ✓ - Step 11: directory contains `manifest.json` and `upload_volume.tar.enc` — no `.sql` file ✓ **T1 PASS** (expected result states SUCCESSFUL or PARTIAL; PARTIAL is explicitly permitted) Now **T2 — per-source isolation**: ● T2 step 1: run list source 2 (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run list qa-test-source-2 2>&1 └ 2 lines… ● T2 step 3: run capture source 2 (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run qa-test-source-2 2>&1 └ 12 lines… R1 = `e0b7f550-2c37-4538-ae10-a236fa62fb25`, R2 = `17ae4242-fa87-430c-8ac5-1081a2aba0e6` ● T2 steps 4-5: list artifact dirs (shell) │ ls local/captures/qa-test-source-1/ 2>&1 && echo "---" && ls local/captures/qa-test-source-2/ │ 2>&1 └ 4 lines… ● T2 step 7: source 2 manifest (shell) │ cat local/captures/qa-test-source-2/17ae4242-fa87-430c-8ac5-1081a2aba0e6/manifest.json 2>&1 └ 25 lines… ● T2 steps 9-10: artifact validate both (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture artifact validate qa-test-source-1 │ e0b7f550-2c37-4538-ae10-a236fa62fb25 2>&1 && echo "---" && PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit │ raw-capture artifact validate qa-test-source-2 17ae4242-fa87-430c-8ac5-1081a2aba0e6 2>&1 └ 12 lines… **T2 Assessment:** - Steps 4–5: distinct dirs, `qa-test-source-1/` only has R1, `qa-test-source-2/` only has R2 ✓ - Steps 6–7: manifests reference correct source_id and run_id each ✓ - Step 8: no cross-contamination (R1 ≠ R2, different ciphertext SHAs, different dirs) ✓ - Steps 9–10: both `artifact validate` exit 0, report VALID, no cross-source conflict ✓ **T2 PASS** Now **T3 — Source status criticality and run history**: ● T3 step 1: source status (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture source status 2>&1 └ 5 lines… ● T3 step 7: source list (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture source list 2>&1 └ 5 lines… **T3 Assessment:** - Step 2: exactly two rows ✓ - Step 3: `qa-test-source-1` shows `[CRITICAL]`, `qa-test-source-2` shows `-` ✓ - Step 4: `LAST_RUN_STATUS` = PARTIAL for source 1 (consistent with T1/T2) ✓ - Step 5: `LAST_SUCCESSFUL` = `never` (all runs were PARTIAL — consistent) ✓ - Step 6: no raw secrets in output ✓ - Step 8: both sources present, `ACCESS_MODE = read_only` ✓ **T3 PASS** Now **T4 — one-source failure does not prevent success on other source**. Step 1 uses `--source-id qa-test-source-2` as a flag — this is the same known syntax issue from the plan's seed data. I need to test whether the CLI accepts this: ● T4 step 1: update source 2 with non-existent path (testing as-written) (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture source update --source-id qa-test-source-2 │ --upload-path /tmp/nonexistent-path-for-test 2>&1; echo "EXIT:$?" └ 4 lines… T4 Step 1 **cannot be executed as written** — the CLI does not accept `--source-id` as a named flag; `SOURCE_ID` is a positional argument. The step errors with `unrecognized arguments: --source-id`. Per rules: *a non-executable step is a defect of the plan*. **T4 is BLOCKED**. Continuing with T5 and T6 (independent of T4): **T5 — Persistence regression** (using run from T1: R1 = `e0b7f550-2c37-4538-ae10-a236fa62fb25`) ● T5 step 1: note run before restart (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run list qa-test-source-1 2>&1 └ 5 lines… T5 Step 1 noted: run `e0b7f550…`, status PARTIAL, timestamps recorded. T5 Step 2–3: "Close the terminal (simulating a process restart)". The CLI is stateless; a new bash invocation simulates this correctly. I'll execute the post-restart steps in a fresh shell: ● T5 step 4: run list after restart (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run list qa-test-source-1 2>&1 └ 5 lines… ● T5 step 6: artifact validate after restart (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture artifact validate qa-test-source-1 │ e0b7f550-2c37-4538-ae10-a236fa62fb25 2>&1 && echo "EXIT:$?" └ 7 lines… ● T5 steps 8-11: source list and status after restart (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture source list 2>&1 && echo "---" && │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture source status 2>&1 └ 10 lines… **T5 Assessment:** - Steps 4–5: run `e0b7f550…` still present, status PARTIAL, same timestamps ✓ - Step 7: `artifact validate` exits 0, VALID ✓ - Steps 9–11: both sources registered with `ACCESS_MODE = read_only`, criticality and run history intact ✓ **T5 PASS** Now **T6 — Secret hygiene regression**. I need to read the password file to compare: ● T6 step 2: confirm password file exists (length only, never printing value) (shell) │ cat local/.secrets/QA_SOURCE_DB_PASSWORD | wc -c 2>&1 && echo "(password length, not value)" └ 3 lines… ● T6 steps 1-5: capture outputs and check for secrets (shell) │ cd /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper │ # Capture all outputs to temp files │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture source list > /tmp/t6_source_list.txt 2>&1 │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture source status > /tmp/t6_source_status.txt │ 2>&1… └ 21 lines… ● T6 steps 6-7: run command and check output for secrets (shell) │ PATH=".venv/bin:$PATH" backup-cockpit raw-capture run qa-test-source-1 > │ /tmp/t6_run_output.txt 2>&1; echo "EXIT:$?" │ # Check run output for secrets │ grep -qF "$(cat local/.secrets/QA_SOURCE_DB_PASSWORD)" /tmp/t6_run_output.txt && echo "FAIL: │ password in run output" || echo "PASS: password not in run output"… └ 21 lines… **T6 Assessment:** - All CLI outputs free of DB password, Fernet key, and SQL plaintext ✓ - Run output contains only metadata (timestamps, status, source ID, run ID) ✓ - Failure reason names step type (`mysqldump exited with code 1`, sanitised), no credential values ✓ **T6 PASS** --- **Summary so far:** - T1: PASS - T2: PASS - T3: PASS - T4: **BLOCKED** — step 1 non-executable as written (plan defect) - T5: PASS - T6: PASS Now I'll also note an **additional plan defect**: the Seed Data section of the Preconditions uses `backup-cockpit raw-capture source update --source-id qa-test-source-1 --critical` — same wrong syntax. This is also a non-executable step (the DevOps Agent corrected it in the deploy answer but the plan itself is wrong). Now creating the blocked document and the history entry: ● Ensure reports dir exists (shell) │ mkdir -p /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/qa/reports └ 1 line… ● Create EPIC_1_E2E_BLOCKED.md +65 └ .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_E2E_BLOCKED.md Now append the history row: ● Append history row (shell) │ HISTORY=/home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/history.md │ if [ ! -f "$HISTORY" ]; then │ echo "| Timestamp | Agent | Scenario | Details |" > "$HISTORY" │ echo "|---|---|---|---|" >> "$HISTORY" │ fi… └ 7 lines… ● Clean up temp files (shell) │ rm -f /tmp/t6_source_list.txt /tmp/t6_source_status.txt /tmp/t6_readiness.txt │ /tmp/t6_run_list.txt /tmp/t6_artifact.txt /tmp/t6_all_outputs.txt /tmp/t6_run_output.txt └ 1 line… --- ## EPIC_1 E2E Validation — Final Report **Environment**: CLI `backup-cockpit`, local workstation, `epic/EPIC_1` @ `adc9d18`. Deployment config: `DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md` | Deployment answer: `DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md` — **READY** (2026-08-05T00:00:42Z). | Test | Verdict | Evidence | |---|---|---| | T1 — Full single-source pipeline: readiness → run → artifact validation | **PASS** | READY status, all 5 checks OK; run `e0b7f550` PARTIAL (permitted); `artifact validate` exits 0, Result: VALID; only `manifest.json` + `upload_volume.tar.enc` in captures dir — no `.sql` file | | T2 — Per-source isolation | **PASS** | Distinct dirs, manifests reference correct source_id/run_id, no cross-contamination, both `artifact validate` exit 0 and VALID | | T3 — Source status: criticality and run history | **PASS** | `[CRITICAL]` for source-1, `-` for source-2; LAST_RUN_STATUS = PARTIAL; LAST_SUCCESSFUL = never (consistent); ACCESS_MODE = read_only for both; no credentials in output | | T4 — One-source failure does not block second source | **BLOCKED** | **Plan defect** — Step 1 uses `--source-id` as a named flag; CLI does not accept it (positional only). Error: `unrecognized arguments: --source-id`. All dependent steps unexecuted. | | T5 — Artifact survives process restart | **PASS** | Run history, artifact validity, source registrations, criticality flags all intact after fresh shell (simulating restart) | | T6 — Secret hygiene regression | **PASS** | All 5 command outputs free of DB password, Fernet key, and SQL plaintext; run output clean | ### Overall Verdict: ❌ NOT VALIDATED (BLOCKED) The epic's E2E validation **does not pass**. T4 is blocked by a **plan defect** that must be corrected by the Product Owner before re-execution. **Action required — Product Owner**: Correct `e2e_test_plan.md` in two places: 1. **T4 Step 1** — change `--source-id qa-test-source-2` to positional: `qa-test-source-2` 2. **Preconditions › Seed Data** — same fix for `source update --source-id qa-test-source-1 --critical` → `source update qa-test-source-1 --critical` The blocked document is at `.milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_E2E_BLOCKED.md`. No bug reports raised (no application FAILs; the blocking cause is a plan authoring error). Changes +65 -0 AI Credits 69.3 (3m 55s) Tokens ↑ 1.2m (1.1m cached, 45.1k written) • ↓ 10.9k (2.6k reasoning) Resume copilot --resume=cfe9b513-26b6-473a-b479-1a27bf5b7f3b