MilkyFlow — milkyflow

← back to History

Run0034_20260805T001004Z
Nodepm_blocker_triage
RolePM
Agentclaude
Result OK
Started2026-08-05T00:06:12.607941+00:00
Duration232.0s
Files changed1
Commits0

Files changed

Briefing

You are the Project Manager Agent.

Based on the rules you must follow in the file .milkyflow/agents/project_manager/rules_project_manager.md,
perform the blocker triage procedure (section 8 of your rules) for the blocked work item
E2E of EPIC_1.

The work item is frozen (QA could not validate it). The blocked document is:
.milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_1_E2E_BLOCKED.md

1. Read it, together with README.md, docs/INDEX.md, and the READMEs of the impacted components.
2. Classify every blocker: A (defective/untestable criterion), B (operational — secrets,
   credentials, infrastructure, spend), C (repository change required — the Solution
   Architect then authors a FIX work item), or D (persistent defect — the SAME defect has
   been reported and re-fixed up to the occurrence threshold and keeps returning; the
   blocked document lists the whole occurrence chain). For D, never route another attempt
   at the same fix: decide what actually changes the outcome, and say why the previous
   attempts failed.
3. Resolve what you can with the knowledge base and tools available. For anything requiring
   CEO authority or a scope decision, write the escalation report at
   .milkyflow/agents/project_manager/reports/EPIC_1_E2E_BLOCKER_$n.md
   following the format in your rules, with concrete options and your recommendation.
4. Do not unfreeze the work item: it resumes only once the report's Resolution section is filled.
5. Register the blocker in docs/INDEX.md.

Output

Blocker triage for EPIC_1 E2E is complete.

**Finding:** T4 in the E2E test plan was blocked on a wrong-syntax step (`source update --source-id <id>` instead of the CLI's required positional `source update <id>`). Verified against `commands.py:787-826` and unit tests — the CLI is correct and intentional (`register` takes `--source-id` as a flag, `update`/`remove`/etc. take it positionally); the defect is purely in the test plan.

**Category A** (defective/untestable criterion) — no code change, no CEO decision needed. I found the same wrong syntax in three spots in `e2e_test_plan.md` (Preconditions Seed data, T4 Step 1, T4 Step 12) plus a still-uncorrected copy in the E2E `DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md` prompt — this exact mistake had already been silently worked around by DevOps twice before (US_4 and this same E2E deploy), which is why I flagged the propagation pattern rather than just patching the one line QA hit.

**Actions taken:**
- Wrote `.milkyflow/agents/project_manager/reports/EPIC_1_E2E_BLOCKER_1.md` with the classification, all four locations needing correction, and a filled Resolution routing to the Product Owner (no CEO required).
- Registered the blocker in `docs/INDEX.md` (Epics row + new Blockers row).
- Appended the mandatory history row.

The E2E session stays frozen — it unfreezes once the Product Owner corrects the test plan, DevOps redeploys, and QA re-runs the full T1–T6 plan.