Files changed

• .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_2_US_1_BLOCKED.md

Briefing

You are the QA Agent.

Based on the rules you must follow in the file .milkyflow/agents/qa/rules_qa_agent.md,
perform the validation of work item US_1 of EPIC_2, specified in
'.milkyflow/agents/product_owner/EPIC_2/US_1.md'.

The acceptance criteria in that file are your test script. Execute them literally, black-box,
against the deployed environment:

- Where to reach the app and test accounts: the "Endpoints" and "Access" sections of
  .milkyflow/agents/devops/prompts/EPIC_2_US_1/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md
- Precondition: .milkyflow/agents/devops/answers/EPIC_2_US_1/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md
  exists and reports READY. If it does not, stop and report: there is no deployed environment.

Do NOT read the developer answer files under .milkyflow/agents/developer/answers/ or any completion
report before testing — they describe what was claimed, and reading them first biases the test.

For each acceptance criterion, record a verdict: PASS / FAIL / BLOCKED.
Also perform the generic negative checks from your rules where applicable (invalid input
produces a clear error, not a crash or silent success; the previous story's core flow still
works).

For every FAIL, create a NEW bug report at .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_2_BUG_$n.md
with the next available bug number, following section 5 of your rules: the `Status: OPEN`
marker, an integer "## Bug Occurrence", and — only if the defect repeats one already reported
in this epic — a "## Previous occurrence" link plus the threshold check
(`qa.max_bug_occurrences`, default 3; at the threshold you escalate to the Project Manager
instead of filing again). A bug is a work item of the EPIC: never attach it to this story.
Record the story only under "## Detected during", which nothing routes on.

The work item is validated only if ALL acceptance criteria PASS. Report the overall verdict.
If it is validated, create the pass document at
.milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_2_US_1_PASS.md following the format in your rules
(section 6) — the Solution Architect cannot start the next work item without it.
If the run does NOT validate the story (any FAIL or BLOCKED), create or update the blocked
document at .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_2_US_1_BLOCKED.md following the same
section — a verdict that lives only in a chat message does not exist.
Cite DEPLOY_CONFIG_1 and the deployment answer in every report's Environment section.

Output

● Read QA rules and check deployment precondition (shell)
  │ cat /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/qa/rules_qa_agent.md
  │ 2>/dev/null; echo "---"; cat /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agen
  │ ts/devops/answers/EPIC_2_US_1/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md 2>/dev/null || echo "FILE_NOT_FOUND"
  └ 20 lines…

● Read rules_qa_agent.md
  │ .milkyflow/agents/qa/rules_qa_agent.md
  └ 433 lines read

● Read deploy config and US_1 spec (shell)
  │ cat /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/devops/answers/EPIC_
  │ 2_US_1/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md 2>/dev/null || echo "FILE_NOT_FOUND"
  │ cat /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/product_owner/EPIC_2
  │ /US_1.md 2>/dev/null
  │ cat /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/devops/prompts/EPIC_…
  └ 383 lines…

The deployment answer reports **READY**. Let me now check the environment and run the acceptance criteria tests.

● Check existing QA reports and config (shell)
  │ ls /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/ 2>/dev/null
  │ && cat /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/config.yml
  │ 2>/dev/null || echo "no config"
  └ 41 lines…

● Check branch and CLI help (shell)
  │ git branch --show-current && source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null; backup-cockpit --help 2>&1;
  │ echo "EXIT:$?"
  └ 14 lines…

● AC1 - register destination (will prompt for password via getpass) (shell)
  │ source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null
  │ # Test AC1 - First registration
  │ echo "=== AC1: Register destination ==="
  │ backup-cockpit live-import destination register qa_dest --base-url https://localhost:8443
  │ --username backup_operator 2>&1…
  └ 11 lines…

● Check correct register flag name (shell)
  │ cat .milkyflow/agents/devops/prompts/EPIC_2_US_1/DEPLOY_CONFIG_1.md | grep -A5 "register"
  └ 48 lines…

The CLI uses `--url` but the spec says `--base-url`. Let me verify:

● Check register help (shell)
  │ source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null && backup-cockpit live-import destination register --help
  │ 2>&1
  └ 19 lines…

The CLI flag is `--url` not `--base-url` (DEPLOY_CONFIG_1 has a documentation mismatch). Let me proceed with actual tests:

● AC1 - register destination with password piped (shell)
  │ source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null
  │ echo "testpassword123" | python -c "
  │ import subprocess, sys
  │ result = subprocess.run(
  │ ['.venv/bin/backup-cockpit', 'live-import', 'destination', 'register', 'qa-dest-1', …
  └ 18 lines…

● AC1 idempotent re-registration + AC5 SQLite check (shell)
  │ source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null
  │
  │ # AC1 - second registration (idempotent), different URL to verify update
  │ python -c "
  │ import subprocess…
  └ 30 lines…

● AC5 - Check SQLite for password presence (shell)
  │ python -c "
  │ import sqlite3
  │ conn = sqlite3.connect('local/backup_cockpit.db')
  │ c = conn.cursor()
  │ c.execute('SELECT * FROM live_import_destinations;')…
  └ 10 lines…

● AC5 - OS credential store + git diff check (shell)
  │ source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null
  │
  │ # Check OS credential store
  │ python -c "
  │ import keyring…
  └ 16 lines…

● Find keyring service name used in source (shell)
  │ source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null
  │
  │ # Check how credential is stored in keyring by looking at source
  │ grep -r "keyring\|credential_key\|get_password\|set_password" src/ --include="*.py" -l
  │ 2>/dev/null…
  └ 51 lines…

● Get service name for live-import credentials (shell)
  │ grep -n "SERVICE_NAME" /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/src/backup_cockpit/li
  │ ve_import/credentials/provider.py
  └ 7 lines…

● Check correct keyring service and key (shell)
  │ source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null
  │ python -c "
  │ import keyring
  │ # The service is 'backup-cockpit-live-import', key is 'live-import-destination:qa-dest-1'
  │ val = keyring.get_password('backup-cockpit-live-import', 'live-import-destination:qa-dest-1')…
  └ 6 lines…

● AC1 - Verify update in place on re-registration (shell)
  │ source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null
  │ # AC1 - Verify idempotent update: register with different URL, check DB
  │ python -c "
  │ import subprocess
  │ result = subprocess.run(…
  └ 24 lines…

● Check if Password Cockpit instance is running (shell)
  │ # Check if any Password Cockpit is running
  │ curl -sk https://localhost:8443/ 2>&1 | head -5
  │ curl -sk https://localhost:8080/ 2>&1 | head -5
  │ curl -sk http://localhost:8080/ 2>&1 | head -5
  │ # Check docker containers…
  └ 3 lines…

● AC3 - readiness check with unreachable destination (shell)
  │ source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null
  │ # Register with a definitely unreachable URL for AC3
  │ python -c "
  │ import subprocess
  │ result = subprocess.run(…
  └ 41 lines…

● Find docker/compose setup files (shell)
  │ find /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper -name "docker-compose*" -o -name
  │ "Dockerfile" -o -name "*.yml" 2>/dev/null | grep -v ".milkyflow\|node_modules\|.git" | head -20
  └ 1 line…

● Find yaml files (shell)
  │ find /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper -name "*.yml" -o -name "*.yaml"
  │ 2>/dev/null | grep -v ".git" | head -20
  └ 15 lines…

● Check for Password Cockpit config (shell)
  │ cat /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/local/.secrets/creds.values.yaml
  │ 2>/dev/null | grep -v "password\|secret\|token\|api_key\|passwd" || echo "no creds file or all
  │ sensitive"
  │ # Check .env for hints about Password Cockpit
  │ cat /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.env 2>/dev/null | grep -v …
  └ 14 lines…

● Check for any running web service (shell)
  │ grep -r "passwordcockpit\|password-cockpit\|password_cockpit\|PasswordCockpit"
  │ /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper --include="*.py" -l 2>/dev/null | head -5
  │ # Check if there's any Password Cockpit running on any port
  │ for port in 80 443 8080 8443 3000 5000; do
  │ curl -sk --connect-timeout 2 http://localhost:$port/ -o /dev/null -w "http://$port: …
  └ 22 lines…

● Negative tests and regression check (shell)
  │ source .venv/bin/activate 2>/dev/null
  │
  │ # Negative test: invalid destination ID (bad characters)
  │ echo "=== Negative: invalid destination ID ==="
  │ python -c "…
  └ 57 lines…

AC1: PASS, AC3: PASS, AC5: PASS. AC2 and AC4 are BLOCKED — no running Password Cockpit instance available. Let me check for existing EPIC_2 bug reports before creating documents:

● Check existing EPIC_2 reports and history (shell)
  │ ls /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_2*
  │ 2>/dev/null || echo "none"
  │ ls
  │ /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/devops/reports/EPIC_2*
  │ 2>/dev/null || echo "no devops EPIC_2 bugs"…
  └ 10 lines…

No existing EPIC_2 bug reports. Now creating the BLOCKED report:

● Create EPIC_2_US_1_BLOCKED.md +103
  └ .milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_2_US_1_BLOCKED.md

Now append to history.md:

● Check history.md header (shell)
  │ cat /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/history.md | head -3
  └ 4 lines…

● Append to history.md (shell)
  │ echo '| 2026-08-05T18:28:00Z | QA — QA Agent | story_validation | {"epic_id": "EPIC_2",
  │ "story_id": "US_1", "config_k": 1, "verdict": "NOT_VALIDATED", "blocked_criteria": ["AC2",
  │ "AC4"], "block_reason": "missing_precondition: no running Password Cockpit instance",
  │ "pass_criteria": ["AC1", "AC3", "AC5"]} |' >>
  │ /home/oem/Documents/Sandbox/Kody/Projects/Backupper/.milkyflow/agents/history.md
  └ 1 line…

---

## QA Run Summary — EPIC_2 US_1

**Overall verdict: NOT VALIDATED (BLOCKED)**

| Criterion | Verdict | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| AC1 — Registration stored | **PASS** | URL in SQLite, password in OS keyring, confirmation shows URL with no password, idempotent upsert confirmed |
| AC2 — Readiness check READY when reachable | **BLOCKED** | No running Password Cockpit instance on QA workstation |
| AC3 — Readiness check NOT READY when unreachable | **PASS** | `network_reachable FAIL` (URL + ConnectError shown), subsequent checks SKIPPED, NOT READY, no password in output |
| AC4 — Readiness check NOT READY with invalid credentials | **BLOCKED** | Requires a reachable (but wrong-cred) instance — same missing service |
| AC5 — Credential in OS store only | **PASS** | No password column in SQLite, git diff CLEAN, keyring entry confirmed present |
| Negative: invalid input → clear error | **PASS** | Invalid ID → clear validation error; unknown destination → clear error |
| Negative: previous story regression (raw-capture) | **PASS** | CLI responds correctly |

**Root cause of BLOCKED criteria:** AC2 and AC4 require a running local Password Cockpit instance (external dependency). None was found on the QA workstation (ports 80/443/8080/8443/3000/5000 all refused/no-response; no Docker containers). This is a **missing precondition** — it cannot be resolved by the delivery loop and requires **Project Manager triage** (PM rules, section 8).

**Artifacts created:**
- `.milkyflow/agents/qa/reports/EPIC_2_US_1_BLOCKED.md` — blocked document
- `.milkyflow/agents/history.md` — execution row appended



Changes    +103 -0
AI Credits 56.2 (4m 1s)
Tokens     ↑ 926.3k (891.3k cached, 34.4k written) • ↓ 10.9k (3.0k reasoning)
Resume     copilot --resume=cc6c7bca-5b24-41d3-8dfd-bde8243e0f92